Geoblogger’s Blog

Geography, GIS, history, landscape, life

What is a map?

From time to time I am asked by students and others what a map is. It is an interesting question and it becomes increasingly difficult to answer. On the web site Maphist, that is by the way a good resource for discussions on old maps you can find over 300 definitions of what a map is defined as during the last 300 years. See also John Krygier’s blog on the topic

I usually include the definition made by ICA (International Cartographic Association) in 1995, but according to the Maphist site it is originally from an earlier source. The ICA celebrates by the way its 50th anniversary this year. Here is the definition:

“A symbolised image of geographic reality, representing selected features or characteristics, resulting from the creative efforts of cartographers, and designed for use when spatial relationships are of special relevance (quoted in Michael Wood, ‘Whither maps and map design’, Bulletin of the Society of Cartographers, xxvii (1993), p. 8).”

I like the fact that creative efforts are included. It means that uncreative cartographers are not making bad maps, they are not making maps at all!! Cartographers should be creative of course. But as a geographer, I’m also sympathetic to¬† the text in the Dictionary of Human Geography (also from the above mentioned Maphist site).

“The map image is a structured cartographic representation of selected spatial information. The image becomes a map when represented physically (e.g. classical topographic map, or braille), virtually (e.g. on a computer screen) or linguistically (e.g. verbal or written spatial instructions) (R.J.Johnston, Derek Gregory and David M.Smith, The dictionary of human geography (3rd edition, Oxford, 1994)).”

The key is selected, and that a map can be virtual and linguistic. Not everybody would agree. I had that discussion recently. Some still prefer to think of maps as something exclusively printed on paper. That is to make it too easy in my opinion because it excludes cartographers when it comes to discussing the look of virtual maps. This is something that cannot be left to the software engineers alone, we see the results everyday on the web.

During the better part of the first 50 years of the ICA the definition of a map was probably not to problematic, but during the coming 50 years spatial information will be used in many ways and the concept of the map will be stretched. Let’s stretch it and do not abandon the many ideas achieved in cartography over the centuries. OK, I realise that we cannot use 18th century ideas with new techniques. No one thought of 3D-visualisation when maps were engraved on copper-plates.

ICA 50years

ICA 50years

Advertisements

Filed under: Cartography, ,

Maps on flags – unclear boundaries?

The map symbolizes the nation. It describes the territory that the government, king etc controls. The flag does more or less the same thing – the banner of the state. It is surprising that so few flags combine these two. The best known banner is the flag of the United Nations. It was created in 1947.

unflag

From time to time you find variants of the map for instance this one below that has the American continents in the centre instead of Africa. This could be a mistake made by someone trying to create a genuine map, but I have not been able to find the origin of it, but it can be found on some places on a couple of blogs on the Internet. They show up if you search for images in google as well.

fake_un-flag

Cyprus

Another obvious example is Cyprus. And this is where it gets interesting. These two flags have two similarities apart from presenting a map. The first one is that there are olive branches symbolizing peace. The second is that they actually do not present the area the organisation cover. Not every country of the world is a member of the UN and Cyprus was divided into two separate parts. So maybe when an area is under question you include the map in your flag. This must have been clear to the new republic of Kosovo, a former part of Yugoslavia (Serbia), where we can see the map under six white, five-pointed stars – each representing one of the major ethnic groups of Kosovo.

kosovo2

Unclear boundaries = lets put the map on the flag!

Filed under: Cartography, , , , ,

Archives

My recent Delicious links